Yubikey vs Password Managers : Which One to Choose? [Detailed Guide]

When it comes to online security, there are a lot of options out there to help protect your personal information. Two of the most popular options are YubiKey and password managers.

Both of these tools provide an extra layer of security for your online accounts, but they work in different ways. So, which one should you choose?

As someone who values online security, I’ve done my fair share of research on the topic.

In this guide, I’ll be breaking down the differences between YubiKey and password managers to help you make an informed decision.

Table of Contents

What are YubiKeys?

Yubikey Homepage

I have found YubiKeys to be a valuable tool in my arsenal. YubiKeys are hardware authentication devices made by Yubico that provide an extra layer of security when logging into online accounts, computers, and networks.

They are small enough to fit on a keychain, making them easy to carry around and use whenever needed.

Features of YubiKey

YubiKeys come in different models, including the YubiKey 5 Series, YubiKey 5 NFC, YubiKey 5Ci, and YubiKey BIO.

Features of Yubikey

Each model has its own set of features, but they all share some common ones:

  • USB-A, USB-C, or Lightning connector for compatibility with different devices
  • NFC and smart card support for contactless authentication
  • Compatibility with various platforms and services, including OATH, OpenPGP, and the Yubico Authenticator
  • Strong hardware-based authentication, including multiple protocols and public key cryptography
  • Radically reduces IT costs, defends against phishing attacks, and eliminates account takeovers

YubiKeys are also compatible with most password managers, making them an excellent alternative to relying solely on a password manager.

What are Password Managers?

Bitwarden Password Manager

As someone who surfs the internet a lot, I have a lot of accounts on different websites. It can be difficult to remember all the passwords for each account. That’s where password managers come in.

Password managers are online services that provide an encrypted vault where you can store the login credentials for all of your online accounts so you don’t have to remember them.

Features of Password Managers

Most password managers have the following features:

  • Password Generation: Password managers can generate strong passwords for you, which are difficult to crack.
  • Autofill: Password managers can autofill login credentials for you, so you don’t have to type them in manually.
  • Encryption: Password managers use encryption to keep your login credentials safe.
  • Cross-Platform Compatibility: Password managers work on multiple platforms, including Windows, macOS, iOS, and Android.
  • Multi-Factor Authentication: Some password managers offer multi-factor authentication, which provides an extra layer of security.
  • Password Sharing: Password managers allow you to share login credentials with others securely.

Some popular password managers include 1Password, LastPass, Dashlane, KeePass, Bitwarden, and Keeper. Each of these services has its own unique features and pricing structure.

Many people are confused between using Browser Password Manager or using a 3rd party Password Manager Tool, well I have answered them all – Read in details

It’s important to do your research and choose a password manager that meets your specific needs.

Vault Report Bitwarden

While password managers are a great way to store login credentials, they do have their limitations.

If someone gains access to your password manager account, they can potentially access all of your login credentials. That’s where YubiKey comes in. YubiKey is a physical security key that provides an extra layer of security for your password manager account.

Uncover the truth: Can YubiKey be hacked? Read this before making your purchase decision.

Which One Should you Choose between Password Managers vs Yubikey?

I have often wondered which is the better option between password managers and Yubikey. Both of these tools are designed to keep your online accounts safe, but which one should you choose?

Factors to Consider

When deciding between password managers and Yubikey, there are several factors to consider. Firstly, you need to think about the level of security you require.

Yubikey offers two-factor authentication, which is considered more secure than a password manager. However, password managers offer a higher level of convenience, allowing you to manage all your passwords in one place.

Another factor to consider is the quality of the tool. Yubikey is known for its durability and crush resistance, making it a great option for those who need a tool that can withstand wear and tear. On the other hand, password managers are known for their user-friendly interface and ease of use.

Use Cases

The decision between password managers and Yubikey also depends on your specific use case. For home users who need to manage passwords for their online accounts, a password manager might be the better option.

However, for those who work in an office or need to access network resources, Yubikey might be the better choice.

Should you use Both of them Together?

It might be a good idea to use both password managers and Yubikey together. This can provide an extra layer of security, especially for those who need to access sensitive information.

Yubico Setup in Bitwarden

This is something I am personally using right now, I added an extra 2FA to my Bitwarden Password Manager Master Password via a YubiKey

While password managers provide a secure way to store and manage passwords, they still require a master password to access all your other passwords. A YubiKey, on the other hand, provides an additional layer of security by requiring a physical key to access your accounts.

Popular Services and Sites

When it comes to compatibility, both password managers and Yubikey work with a wide range of popular services and sites.

Yubi Accesss

Some of the most popular services that work with password managers include Google, Dropbox, Facebook, Twitter, and Github.

Yubikey, on the other hand, works with services such as Opera, Gmail, Coinbase, Microsoft, and Okta.

I share my Learnings & Case studies via email.
Subscribe to Stay Updated


In conclusion, both YubiKey and password managers offer reliable solutions for securing your online accounts. YubiKey provides an extra layer of security by requiring a physical key for authentication, while password managers offer convenience and ease of use by storing and generating complex passwords for you.

When deciding which one to choose, it ultimately comes down to personal preference and specific needs. If you prioritize convenience and simplicity, a password manager may be the better option for you. On the other hand, if you prioritize security and are willing to invest in a physical key, YubiKey may be the way to go.

It’s important to note that while YubiKey and password managers can greatly enhance your online security, they are not foolproof. It’s still important to practice good password hygiene, such as using unique passwords for each account and regularly updating them.

Aditya R Sharma

Hello! Currently, I am working as Chief Marketing Officer at POSIMYTH Innovations, with a deep love for WordPress. I love solving problem with AI, Automations & Critical planning. In my free time, I write blogs to share all his learnings with the internet.

Content Writing for SaaS & WordPress Business
Tired of Low Traffic & see your Blog Fail?

Let me help you with content writing & SEO strategy for your product that makes sales.

After raising multiple domains to 1M+ organic click, I am helping Business owners like you harness the real power of SEO.

Explore Further